InherentSafety Westray

Information about InherentSafety Westray

Published on December 10, 2007

Author: Abbott

Source: authorstream.com

Content

AN INHERENT SAFETY BASED INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY:  AN INHERENT SAFETY BASED INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY Attiq Goraya, Dalhousie University Paul Amyotte, Dalhousie University Faisal Khan, Memorial University Loss Prevention Symposium AIChE April 29, 2004 OUTLINE :  OUTLINE Introduction Incident Investigation Inherent Safety Principles of Inherent Safety Incident Investigation Methodology Case Study: Westray Mine Explosion Concluding Remarks INTRODUCTION:  INTRODUCTION Scope: Development of a methodology or protocol For incident investigation Explicitly incorporating principles of inherent safety via guidewords and checklist Motivation: Inherent safety focus within research group Also emphasis on use of case studies for validation In case of Westray, due to its extreme nature, use of case study for methodology development INCIDENT INVESTIGATION:  INCIDENT INVESTIGATION The process by which underlying causes of an incident are uncovered and steps are taken to prevent recurrence A well-recognized and vital part of Process Safety Management (PSM) Element 9 in CSChE PSM Guide (based on CCPS approach) INHERENT SAFETY :  INHERENT SAFETY How we deal with hazards: Inherent Safety Engineered Safety (add-on devices) Passive Active Procedural Safety (administrative controls) INHERENT SAFETY :  INHERENT SAFETY Early work done in late 1970’s by Trevor Kletz (ICI & Loughborough University) Regarded as the “father” of inherent safety What you don’t have can’t leak Leading proponent in US is Dennis Hendershot (among others, e.g. Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Center) Efforts worldwide: e.g. UK, Finland, Singapore, US, Canada CJChE, vol 81, pp. 2-16 (2003) INHERENT SAFETY :  INHERENT SAFETY From dictionary – “inherent” Belonging to the very nature of a person or a thing Stresses the inseparability of a part, element or quality Characteristics of a design which prevent hazards or mitigate consequences Utilize underlying physics and chemistry PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY :  PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY Four main principles of inherent safety are: Minimization Substitution Moderation Simplification PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY :  PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY Minimization: Minimize amount of hazardous material in use (when use of such materials cannot be avoided – i.e. elimination) PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY :  PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY Substitution: Replace substance with less hazardous material; replace process route with one involving less hazardous materials PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY:  PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY Moderation: Use hazardous materials in least hazardous forms; run process equipment with less severe operating conditions (e.g. T and P) PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY :  PRINCIPLES OF INHERENT SAFETY Simplification: Simplify equipment and processes that are used; avoid complexities; make equipment robust; eliminate opportunities for error INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY:  INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY Combination of Syncrude Canada protocol CCPS guidelines Bird and Germain domino loss causation model Kletz’s layered model Stages Preparation and initial response Data gathering Data analysis Recommendation reporting, implementation and follow-up INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY:  INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY Integrated approach to loss management People Property (assets) Production (business interruption) Environment Incorporation of inherent safety Guidewords Checklist INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY:  INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY . Team Planning Incident Loss Notification to Activate Team On-Site Investigation Identification of Immediate Causes Identification of Basic Causes Lack of Management Control Factors Recommendations Implement Recommendations Follow-Up Inherent Safety Guidewords Inherent Safety Checklist Inherent Safety Guidewords People Property Production Environment Position People Parts Paper Immediate/ Technical Avoid Hazards Improve Management System INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY:  INCIDENT INVESTIGATION METHODOLOGY . Team Planning Incident Loss Notification to Activate Team On-Site Investigation Identification of Immediate Causes Inherent Safety Guidewords People Property Production Environment Position People Parts Paper Inherent Safety Checklist .:  . . Identification of Lack of Management Control Factors Recommendations Implement Recommendations Follow-Up Inherent Safety Checklist Identification of Basic Causes Inherent Safety Guidewords Immediate/ Technical Avoid Hazards Improve Management System INHERENT SAFETY GUIDEWORDS:  INHERENT SAFETY GUIDEWORDS Minimize: Use smaller quantities of hazardous materials when the use of such materials cannot be avoided. Perform a hazardous procedure as few times as possible when the procedure is unavoidable. Substitute: Replace a substance with a less hazardous material or processing route with one that does not involve hazardous material. Replace a hazardous procedure with one that is less hazardous. Moderate: Use hazardous materials in their least hazardous forms or identify processing options that involve less severe processing conditions. Simplify: Design processes, processing equipment, and procedures to eliminate opportunities for errors by eliminating excessive use of add-on (engineered) safety features and protective devices. INHERENT SAFETY CHECKLIST:  INHERENT SAFETY CHECKLIST INHERENT SAFETY CHECKLIST:  INHERENT SAFETY CHECKLIST CASE STUDY: WESTRAY MINE EXPLOSION:  CASE STUDY: WESTRAY MINE EXPLOSION WESTRAY:  WESTRAY Coal mining has been an integral part of Pictou County (Nova Scotia) history since the first commercial mine opened in Stellarton in 1807, to the closing of the Drummond mine in Westville in 1974. On September 11, 1991 Westray opened a new mine in Plymouth. At 5:20 am on May 9, 1992 after only eight months of operation, an explosion ripped through the mine killing 26 men who were underground at the time. INCIDENT:  INCIDENT There was an explosion in the Westray mine on the morning of May 9, 1992. Fuel Oxidant Ignition Source . Fire Triangle Ignition Source Fuel Oxidant LOSS:  LOSS Losses resulting from Westray explosion include: Deaths of 26 miners Destruction of mining equipment and the mine itself Bankruptcy of the parent company Default of millions of dollars in government loans ON-SITE INVESTIGATION:  ON-SITE INVESTIGATION The objectives of on-site activities are to gather information used for determining root causes. Position, People, Parts, Paper – IS Guidewords Methane: Methane layering provided a rich source of fuel for the explosion in the presence of an ignition source. Coal Dust: According to Richard (1997) coal dust at least ankle-deep accumulated on many of the underground roadways, making foot travel difficult. ON-SITE INVESTIGATION:  ON-SITE INVESTIGATION Non-Flameproof vehicles: According to Richard (1997) there were instances in which workers, supervisors and management employed non-flameproof vehicles underground. Fuel Storage: Fuel for mining machinery was improperly stored underground (Richard, 1997). Auxiliary Ventilation System: Westray used auxiliary fans in the exhaust mode (Richard, 1997). IMMEDIATE CAUSES:  IMMEDIATE CAUSES Immediate causes are divided into two broad categories: Substandard Practices IMMEDIATE CAUSES:  IMMEDIATE CAUSES Substandard Conditions BASIC CAUSES:  BASIC CAUSES Basic causes are divided into two broad categories: Personal Factors BASIC CAUSES:  BASIC CAUSES Job Factors LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS:  LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS Inadequate Program Elements: (adopted from Amyotte and Oehmen, 2002) Management commitment and accountability to safety matters Incident investigation Training (orientation, task-related, etc.) Task definitions and safe work practices and procedures Workplace inspections and more detailed hazard identification methodologies Program evaluation and audit LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS:  LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS Inadequate Program Standards: (adopted from Amyotte and Oehmen, 2002) Management’s concern toward safety matters Follow-through on inspections for substandard practices and conditions Action on hazard reports submitted by employees Job instructions for employees Equipment maintenance Scheduling of management/employee meetings to discuss safety concerns LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS:  LACK OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL FACTORS Inadequate Compliance with Standards: (adopted from Amyotte and Oehmen, 2002) Poor correlation between management actions and official company policy concerning the relationship between safety and production Compliance to industry practice and legislated standards concerning numerous aspects of coal mining: methane concentrations, rock dusting, control of ignition sources underground, etc. RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Immediate Technical Recommendations: Use of IS Guidewords Removal of coal dust accumulations would have immediate benefits. Relocation of the fuel and the vehicles to the surface would have an immediate positive effect. RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Recommendations to Avoid the Hazard: Use of Principle Minimize Methane Degasification Adequate ventilation design and system Coal Dust Length of shift Non-flameproof equipment (ignition sources) Storing fuel underground RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Use of Principle Substitute Auxiliary ventilation system: forcing, rather than exhaust, system for adequate airflow to clear methane from the working face of the mine Main ventilation fan: alternate design and location so as not to pick up dust and other debris from the coal return conveyor belt RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Use of Principle Moderate Purchase of adequate rock dust inventory Implementation of rock dusting program Roadway consolidation RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Use of Principle Simplify Installation of a reliable, robust mine air monitoring system RECOMMENDATIONS:  RECOMMENDATIONS Recommendations to Improve the Management System: SYSTEM + ATTITUDE Program elements such as hiring procedures, training, safe work procedures, and hazard identification Program standards such as appropriate follow-through on inspection results Compliance issues relating to both internal and external standards. CONCLUDING REMARKS:  CONCLUDING REMARKS A methodology has been developed to enable the explicit use of inherent safety principles (minimize, substitute, moderate and simplify) in an incident investigation protocol. Application of the methodology to the Westray coal mine explosion has demonstrated how a lack of inherent safety considerations played a key role in the incident occurrence and severity. What can the CPI learn from a coal mine explosion?:  What can the CPI learn from a coal mine explosion? Westray was a process safety incident, not simply OH&S. “Worker safety not my responsibility, says ex-Westray engineer” (newspaper headline) is not an acceptable attitude. Management system deficiencies were at the core. “Lessons from Longford” by Andrew Hopkins (CCH Australia Limited, 2000) relates essentially the same story by drawing parallels between a coal mine explosion and a gas plant explosion in Australia. In Nova Scotia, the lessons learned have led to a new OH&S Act which is underpinned by the Internal Responsibility System. In Canada, the lessons learned have led to changes in the Criminal Code of Canada (Bill C-45) regarding criminal negligence charges for inappropriate corporate level behaviour. When educating ChE students at Dalhousie University, it is important to consider Westray as well as Flixborough, Bhopal,…

Related presentations


Other presentations created by Abbott

Fantastic Pictures
31. 07. 2007
0 views

Fantastic Pictures

jovanovi
02. 05. 2008
0 views

jovanovi

ours2
30. 04. 2008
0 views

ours2

golding
28. 04. 2008
0 views

golding

SandersD
22. 04. 2008
0 views

SandersD

MasterclassBasicsOfH edging
18. 04. 2008
0 views

MasterclassBasicsOfH edging

Energy Management Basics
17. 04. 2008
0 views

Energy Management Basics

jpn ma
13. 04. 2008
0 views

jpn ma

0802 Roderick Deane
10. 04. 2008
0 views

0802 Roderick Deane

Athirapally Vazhachaal Falls
26. 09. 2007
0 views

Athirapally Vazhachaal Falls

Lecture7
10. 10. 2007
0 views

Lecture7

qa overview cmu
16. 10. 2007
0 views

qa overview cmu

11 GUIDE presentation Porvoo 10
19. 10. 2007
0 views

11 GUIDE presentation Porvoo 10

Egyptian Quiz
21. 10. 2007
0 views

Egyptian Quiz

AGE200524122005
24. 10. 2007
0 views

AGE200524122005

Henry VIII wwt bam
21. 08. 2007
0 views

Henry VIII wwt bam

DOE LNG FORUM 14
07. 11. 2007
0 views

DOE LNG FORUM 14

matzgdh6
22. 10. 2007
0 views

matzgdh6

BdReviewFINAL2006 lq
16. 11. 2007
0 views

BdReviewFINAL2006 lq

session2
20. 11. 2007
0 views

session2

lecture26 fall 2003
19. 11. 2007
0 views

lecture26 fall 2003

WWF
26. 11. 2007
0 views

WWF

Chocolate 01
03. 10. 2007
0 views

Chocolate 01

MARE 494 Lecture 12
12. 10. 2007
0 views

MARE 494 Lecture 12

ErnestoRivera
22. 10. 2007
0 views

ErnestoRivera

tema1
24. 10. 2007
0 views

tema1

Libecap powerpoint
04. 01. 2008
0 views

Libecap powerpoint

Assam
05. 01. 2008
0 views

Assam

Samuels Mol Pharm 11 03
24. 02. 2008
0 views

Samuels Mol Pharm 11 03

Stock Market Game
24. 02. 2008
0 views

Stock Market Game

nv specialitypp
29. 10. 2007
0 views

nv specialitypp

104 04MagnConst
13. 11. 2007
0 views

104 04MagnConst

clingan
04. 03. 2008
0 views

clingan

EARNIN x007E 1 2
23. 10. 2007
0 views

EARNIN x007E 1 2

aes
13. 03. 2008
0 views

aes

Semprini
16. 03. 2008
0 views

Semprini

KPMG PresentationSMEfinal
26. 03. 2008
0 views

KPMG PresentationSMEfinal

temple of Zeus
21. 08. 2007
0 views

temple of Zeus

Australia 2 March 20051
28. 09. 2007
0 views

Australia 2 March 20051

maillistnews
05. 10. 2007
0 views

maillistnews

feb 5
27. 09. 2007
0 views

feb 5

ykis06 K F Liu
15. 11. 2007
0 views

ykis06 K F Liu

schreiber
12. 10. 2007
0 views

schreiber

Pisani
30. 10. 2007
0 views

Pisani

200752414331362
11. 10. 2007
0 views

200752414331362

decisiontheoryreview
04. 01. 2008
0 views

decisiontheoryreview

a Macroecologia Alimentar 2
22. 10. 2007
0 views

a Macroecologia Alimentar 2

praesentationschule
02. 11. 2007
0 views

praesentationschule

Wireless Data Business
18. 06. 2007
0 views

Wireless Data Business

WHA userguide Customer2006
18. 06. 2007
0 views

WHA userguide Customer2006

wales
18. 06. 2007
0 views

wales

VON04s I2
18. 06. 2007
0 views

VON04s I2

UTeV Rick Field 12 14 06
18. 06. 2007
0 views

UTeV Rick Field 12 14 06

UDDI Overview Presentation
18. 06. 2007
0 views

UDDI Overview Presentation

2006 02 28T124652
25. 03. 2008
0 views

2006 02 28T124652

SoprolecheAgo 2005
23. 10. 2007
0 views

SoprolecheAgo 2005

ZadehTalk
18. 10. 2007
0 views

ZadehTalk

ihepccc hepix
24. 10. 2007
0 views

ihepccc hepix

jedwards
02. 10. 2007
0 views

jedwards

Wireless Mobile Platform OAEP
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Wireless Mobile Platform OAEP

Taverna Workbench
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Taverna Workbench

Job Services with Genius Portal
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Job Services with Genius Portal

MSN screenshots
15. 06. 2007
0 views

MSN screenshots

Caltech, Peck Fest Jan 05
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Caltech, Peck Fest Jan 05

rslt3218
17. 10. 2007
0 views

rslt3218

6 26
17. 10. 2007
0 views

6 26

vp sigmetrics 04 adversaries
18. 06. 2007
0 views

vp sigmetrics 04 adversaries

calcagno
22. 10. 2007
0 views

calcagno

LegoDesign
31. 12. 2007
0 views

LegoDesign

Ted Hanss Internet2
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Ted Hanss Internet2

Mary and Darnley
21. 08. 2007
0 views

Mary and Darnley

1 partie
17. 10. 2007
0 views

1 partie

Techmission Safe Families
15. 06. 2007
0 views

Techmission Safe Families

Camille Page CrocodileGuy MK8
11. 10. 2007
0 views

Camille Page CrocodileGuy MK8

Salandayia
04. 10. 2007
0 views

Salandayia

B4 Hamilton
03. 01. 2008
0 views

B4 Hamilton

SEC062804
25. 10. 2007
0 views

SEC062804